Editorial

The ripple effect of prison closures

Posted 11/18/21

Gov. Kathy Hochul’s announcement last week of her plans to close six state prisons in March, though hailed as a cost-saving measure of $142 million per year, is not drawing much praise in the …

This item is available in full to subscribers.

Please log in to continue

Log in
Editorial

The ripple effect of prison closures

Posted

Gov. Kathy Hochul’s announcement last week of her plans to close six state prisons in March, though hailed as a cost-saving measure of $142 million per year, is not drawing much praise in the Hudson Valley. The largest of prisons to close will be the Downstate Correctional Facility in Fishkill.

The move apparently caught local officials by surprise.

“There has been no coordination between the Governor’s Office and Dutchess County on the closure of this large facility, nor a coordinated plan for the future use of the parcel and the hundreds of workers who will be affected,” Dutchess County Executive Marc Molinaro told the Westchester Business Journal. Molinaro, a onetime gubernatorial candidate, recently announced plans to run for Congress next year in New York’s 19th District, which includes Dutchess and Ulster Counties.
The decision also prompted a statement of condemnation from Assemblyman Colin J. Schmitt of New Windsor. He has similar congressional aspirations for the district that includes Orange County.

Downstate currently has 690 prisoners, roughly half its capacity, according to the Department of Corrections and Community Supervision (DOCCS), which notes that the state’s prison population has declined by nearly 30 percent since January 2020 and by 57 percent since 1999. The 31,469 people incarcerated by the state is the lowest number since 1984, the DOCCS added.

The plan calls for Downstate’s Maximum Security prisoners to be relocated to empty cells throughout the state. The Willard Drug Treatment Campus will be relocated to Chautauqua County; the work release program at Rochester will move to Orleans County; and the Elmira Correctional Facility in Chemung County will absorb prisoners who would have gone to Downstate, which serves as a reception facility for inmates entering the state system.

As for the 644 downstate employees, the state is promising no layoffs, but that it will “work closely with the various bargaining units to provide staff with opportunities for priority placement via voluntary transfers, as well as priority employment at other facilities or other state agencies.”

In other words, some may find their way to Shawangunk, Wallkill or other state-run facilities. Some may end up working for other state agencies. Some may even opt for voluntarily retirement. Few, if any, will see no disruption to their lives in the Hudson Valley.

Prison workers shop in local stores, send their kids to local schools, eat in local restaurants and, of course, pay local taxes. Therein lies the ripple effect of the closure. And it’s not just the 644 currently employed. It’s also a lost career opportunity for young people coming out of school who may want to follow the footsteps of a prior generation.

That’s a lot to absorb. And 90 days is not a lot of time in which to absorb it.