Mary McTamaney
By Mary McTamaney
Thanksgiving is just a week away. It will be the good fortune of most people to be surrounded by family and friends. After warm greetings and hugs, we will tuck around a table and share some favorite foods during a multi-course meal. Then, many families walk off their big feast, if the weather cooperates, by roaming around a few blocks of their neighborhood. That is when Newburghers field all the questions about “what’s new?” in this historic old city. For me, living far downtown, it is also when someone asks what used to be here as we walk past so many incomplete cityscapes.
My ancestors took their Thanksgiving Day walks along streets packed with commerce. On a holiday like this when stores were closed, they window-shopped and let youngsters chatter about what they hoped to get for Hanukkah or Christmas. Often, they headed toward the Hudson River and sat on a bench to watch the river traffic. One special watchpoint was Broadway Park – the landscaped steps that lead from Broadway down to Water Street. That little park, a crucial pedestrian link between Water Street and Booadway, was once surrounded by the three-story brick buildings of Colden Street, Washington Place and South Water Street. From that vantage point, all the passenger and freight boats could be clearly seen. Newburgh always struggled with its hilly streets but they did afford a wide perspective as pedestrians climbed up each block. Resting places like the courthouse park and the lawn of the Dutch Reformed Church offered views down Third and Second Streets to the commercial center and to the river. Downing Park, a longer walk up Third Street, was the greatest perch for seeing the expansive vista of Newburgh Bay. Of course, Washington’s Headquarters great lawn was a wonderful place to walk off a big feast and let children run off their excitement. Then families headed home unless they had the spare change to board the ferry and ride over to Beacon and back, sitting in the old passenger cabins with the “ferryboat seats” of beaded oak.
For strolling Newburghers, probably the best Thanksgiving window displays were in Schoonmaker’s Department Store that occupied four buildings on Water Street between Third and Fourth Streets and more than a half-block along Front Street too. Schoonmaker’s was a complete old-style department store where everything from clothing and furniture to linens, fabrics, kitchenware and toys were arranged inside its three stories. No modern big box store can match its variety and quality.
My husband and I went down to the waterfront to our favorite shoreline restaurant, Café Pitti, recently. After coding in costly payment for our parking place via the infuriating meter app, we walked along a sidewalk much narrower than those that once lined Front Street. We winced at the roar of the CSX freight train passing above us on the massive stone trestle that had been sheltered by stores in our youth. We tip-toed around dumpsters that would have been too offensive for merchants to use in the mid-20th century and together we tried to recall all that had been built along Front Street by earlier Newburghers.
No one will be able to rebuild along that trestle again because of the commerce regulations that protect railroad right-of-ways. Yet, looking back may provide some guidance to those looking forward. What can be inserted into our increasingly quiet waterfront that might attract the parade of Thanksgiving walkers many of us remember?